Rule-following, legal precedence, and political consistency are not more important than right, justice and plain common-sense.

In this quote, W. E. B. Du Bois emphasizes that rule-following, legal precedence, and political consistency should not outweigh the principles of right, justice, and common sense. Du Bois is advocating for a higher moral standard in decision-making, suggesting that adherence to the law and political norms should not be prioritized over ensuring fairness and ethical correctness. He stresses that laws and political systems are tools to achieve justice, not ends in themselves, and they must be used to serve the greater good.

Du Bois’s statement critiques a rigid, formalistic approach to law and governance, arguing that such an approach can sometimes lead to injustice or perpetuate inequality. He highlights the importance of ethical considerations in decision-making, particularly in situations where laws may be outdated, discriminatory, or unjust. By emphasizing common sense, Du Bois advocates for the application of practical wisdom and moral reasoning in political and legal matters, particularly when dealing with issues of civil rights and social justice.

The origin of this quote lies in Du Bois’s role as a civil rights activist, sociologist, and writer who consistently critiqued the American legal and political systems for their treatment of African Americans. His work, including his involvement with the NAACP and his influential writings such as The Souls of Black Folk, often challenged the prevailing legal and political structures, advocating instead for a society built on the principles of equality, justice, and human dignity.

Ultimately, Du Bois’s quote calls for a critical examination of the law and its role in promoting justice. He encourages individuals and leaders to prioritize ethical and moral values over blind adherence to established norms, advocating for a justice system that serves all people fairly, especially those who have been historically marginalized.