No, I don't think I've ever really favoured English independence. My view is that if the Scots want to be independent then we should aim for the same thing.

In this quote, Roger Scruton discusses his perspective on English independence in relation to the ongoing debate about the independence of Scotland. Scruton makes it clear that he doesn't support the idea of England becoming independent, but rather suggests that if the Scottish people wish to pursue independence, then England should consider seeking the same. His view reflects a broader reflection on the dynamics of national identity and the concept of autonomy within the United Kingdom.

Scruton’s statement suggests a more egalitarian approach to the idea of independence, where if one part of the union seeks self-determination, it should be met with similar respect and consideration for other parts of the union, such as England. This reflects a belief in the right to self-governance for all nations and regions within the UK. Rather than treating independence as something that only one nation within the union can claim, Scruton suggests that it should be a possibility for all if the political conditions align.

The origin of this quote lies in Scruton’s views on political philosophy and his often nuanced thoughts on national sovereignty. As a philosopher and writer, he frequently explored ideas around cultural identity and national unity. His comments on independence come within the context of the Scottish independence movement, where debates about whether Scotland should remain part of the United Kingdom continue to shape political discourse.

In essence, Scruton’s quote emphasizes a more balanced view on independence and self-determination within the UK. While not advocating for English independence outright, he recognizes the importance of allowing autonomy for all nations within the union, including Scotland and England. This perspective underscores the complexities surrounding national identity and the right to decide one’s own political future.