When there is state there can be no freedom, but when there is freedom there will be no state.

The quote "When there is state there can be no freedom, but when there is freedom there will be no state" by Vladimir Lenin reflects his views on the relationship between the state and individual liberty. Lenin believed that a state—as an institution of power and control—inevitably limits personal freedom. In his view, the state's authority, with its laws, regulations, and enforcement, suppresses the true expression of human liberty. Therefore, true freedom could not exist as long as the state exercised its control over individuals.

The origin of this quote is rooted in Lenin's revolutionary ideology, particularly his belief in the need for a proletarian revolution to overthrow existing governmental structures. As a key figure in the Russian Revolution and the establishment of the Soviet Union, Lenin sought to dismantle the capitalist state and replace it with a socialist society. His view was that once the state had been abolished, a classless society would emerge where people would live freely without the constraints of centralized power.

Lenin's philosophy reflects his strong belief in Marxism, which advocates for the dissolution of the state as a means to ensure true equality and freedom. He argued that in a world where the people are free, there would be no need for a state apparatus to enforce laws, as society would be self-regulating. This would allow for the elimination of oppression and the realization of a society where individuals could live without restrictions imposed by an external authority.

The quote encapsulates Lenin's vision of a utopian society where the state is no longer necessary because freedom is fully realized. However, this view has been controversial, as critics argue that the absence of a state could lead to chaos or anarchy. Nevertheless, Lenin's words continue to resonate in discussions about the role of the state and individual liberty in political theory.