We want order and security, and we want liberty. And we want not only liberty but equality as well.

David Souter’s quote emphasizes the balance between order, security, liberty, and equality in a well-functioning society. He argues that liberty—the freedom to act and think without undue restraint—should not be pursued at the expense of other values such as order and security. However, he goes a step further by asserting that equality must also be a core component of this balance. Souter implies that true liberty cannot be achieved unless equality is ensured for all individuals, because freedom in an unequal society is often limited or skewed by social, economic, and political disparities.

The quote reflects the constitutional values Souter, as a U.S. Supreme Court Justice, upheld during his tenure on the Court. His statement suggests that a society’s commitment to freedom should include the protection of equal rights and opportunities for everyone, regardless of their status or background. This belief aligns with the American ideals enshrined in the Constitution, which promise both liberty and equality, though often the struggle to realize these ideals fully is ongoing.

By invoking both liberty and equality, Souter draws attention to the tension that often exists between individual freedoms and the need for collective well-being. He suggests that the pursuit of justice should not be limited to granting individual freedom alone but should also include ensuring that people are treated equally under the law. In this view, a truly just society is one where all citizens are free to pursue their goals while being protected from discrimination or inequality.

Originating from Souter’s background as a Supreme Court Justice, the quote reflects his long-standing commitment to the principles of justice, liberty, and equality. As a jurist, Souter was known for his nuanced approach to constitutional law, often emphasizing the importance of balancing individual rights with the needs of the community. His recognition of the intersection between security, freedom, and equality speaks to his broader belief in the importance of these values in sustaining a just and equitable society.