I do believe that people hire immigrants, legal and illegal immigrants, to do certain jobs that maybe possibly could go to American citizens, and that's unfortunate. If they're here legally, I think it's OK. If they're here illegally, then they ought not be taking jobs from American citizens.

In this quote, Jan Brewer expresses her belief that both legal and illegal immigrants are often hired to perform jobs that could potentially be filled by American citizens. She acknowledges that immigrants, particularly those working illegally, are taking on jobs that she feels should be reserved for U.S. citizens. However, she also states that if immigrants are here legally, she finds it acceptable for them to hold these positions. Brewer’s statement reflects a common debate about the role of immigration in the U.S. workforce, particularly in terms of competition for jobs between immigrants and native-born citizens.

The origin of this quote lies in Brewer’s political views and her stance on immigration reform. As the Governor of Arizona, Brewer was a vocal advocate for stricter immigration laws, particularly with regard to the enforcement of policies that would prevent illegal immigration. Her views align with a more restrictive approach to immigration, where immigrants in the country illegally are seen as a threat to American jobs and economic stability.

Brewer’s distinction between legal and illegal immigration is crucial in her argument. She argues that if immigrants are in the country legally, they should have the right to work, while those who are here illegally should not have access to employment. This reflects a viewpoint often held by those who believe that illegal immigration creates unfair competition in the job market, potentially driving down wages or limiting opportunities for American workers.

Ultimately, this quote highlights Brewer’s position on immigration and the labor market, suggesting that while she sees value in legal immigration, she is concerned about the negative impact of illegal immigration on American jobs. Her statement adds to the broader debate on how immigration should be regulated and the economic consequences of allowing undocumented workers to hold jobs in the U.S.