Games of chance often involve some amount of skill; this does not make them legal. Good poker players often beat novices. But poker is still gambling, and running a poker room - or online casino - is illegal in New York.

In this quote, Eric Schneiderman discusses the distinction between games of chance and games that involve skill, such as poker. He acknowledges that while some games, like poker, require skill to succeed, this does not necessarily make them legal under the law. Schneiderman uses the example of good poker players being able to beat novices to emphasize that skill can influence the outcome, but it does not change the fact that poker is still considered a form of gambling, which has legal restrictions.

The origin of this quote stems from Schneiderman's role as the Attorney General of New York, where he was responsible for enforcing state laws, including those regulating gambling. The quote serves as a reminder that certain activities, even if they involve skill, are still subject to legal scrutiny. Schneiderman specifically points out that activities such as running a poker room or an online casino are still illegal in New York, regardless of how much skill or strategy may be involved.

Schneiderman’s statement reflects the ongoing tension between the regulation of gambling and the growing popularity of skill-based games like poker. Despite the skill involved, these games are still classified under gambling laws, which are intended to protect individuals from potential financial harm and prevent illegal activities related to unregulated betting. His remark highlights the complexity of legal distinctions between different types of games and their legal status.

Ultimately, this quote underscores Schneiderman’s view that legal regulations are designed to safeguard the public, and that skill does not necessarily exempt an activity from being classified as gambling. It serves as a reminder that the line between legal and illegal activities can be nuanced, and that all forms of gambling, including those based on skill, are subject to the rules set by law.