How can you tell when a political ideology has become the equivalent of a religion?

In this quote, Andrew Sullivan, a political commentator and writer, raises a thought-provoking question about the nature of political ideologies and their potential to transform into religions. He suggests that there is a point at which a political belief system, once grounded in reason and rational discourse, begins to take on characteristics typically associated with religion—such as dogmatism, infallibility, and the unquestionable authority of its leaders or principles. The question challenges us to reflect on the extent to which political movements can shift from being a means of addressing societal issues to a faith-based system where critical thinking is replaced by blind allegiance.

Sullivan's comment taps into a larger conversation about the role of ideology in modern society. As ideologies become more entrenched, they can take on a zealous or devotional quality, leading followers to adopt rigid beliefs that are no longer subject to debate or change. This parallels the way many religions function, where the teachings and doctrines are seen as absolute truths rather than evolving ideas. Sullivan’s question invites us to consider how ideological movements—especially those with intense followers—can resemble religions in their capacity to shape the worldview and identity of their adherents.

The origin of this quote is likely rooted in Sullivan’s broader critique of both politics and culture. Known for his thoughtful and often contrarian takes, Sullivan has frequently explored the intersection of political beliefs and identity formation. He has written extensively on topics such as liberalism, conservatism, and the culture wars, frequently critiquing the way ideologies can become infused with irrationality or intolerance. In this case, his question about political ideologies becoming akin to religions invites readers to reflect on how belief systems—whether religious or political—can shape lives in ways that sometimes limit open-mindedness and critical inquiry.

Ultimately, Sullivan’s quote challenges us to examine the nature of ideologies and to ask whether we might be unknowingly transforming our political convictions into something that resembles faith. By asking when a political ideology becomes like a religion, he underscores the importance of maintaining a healthy sense of self-awareness, critical thinking, and openness to change in the face of strong beliefs. It serves as a reminder to not let any ideology—political or otherwise—become so entrenched that it stops evolving and begins to take on the unshakable certainty of a religious conviction.