You really have no idea whether or not what you're writing is funny. In stand-up and sketch comedy, you know right away and you can make your changes accordingly.

In this quote, Michael Showalter reflects on the uncertainty that often comes with writing, particularly when it comes to creating something funny. Unlike stand-up or sketch comedy, where the response from the audience is immediate and clear, the process of writing—whether it be for television, film, or other formats—doesn’t offer that same instant feedback. Showalter highlights the challenge of not knowing whether something will resonate with an audience until it's shared, which can make the writing process feel uncertain.

In contrast, stand-up and sketch comedy offer instant feedback. When performing live, comedians can gauge the audience's response in real time, adjusting their delivery or material based on whether it's eliciting laughter. This immediate interaction provides comedians with a level of control over the performance, allowing them to make changes on the spot to ensure the material lands well with the crowd. Showalter contrasts this immediate response with the slower, more indirect feedback of writing.

Showalter's comment underscores the different dynamics involved in writing versus performing comedy. In writing, there is often a sense of anticipation and uncertainty because writers can’t be sure if their material will succeed until it’s presented. In live performances, however, comedians benefit from the direct connection with their audience, making the craft of stand-up and sketch comedy more immediate and interactive.

Ultimately, Showalter’s quote illustrates how comedic writing requires a level of patience and faith, as the process lacks the instant validation that live performance provides. It also draws attention to the different skills required for each form of comedy, where the immediacy of performance contrasts with the more delayed nature of writing.