The alternative to independence is decline, because the relationship with the Spanish state is not good; everyone knows that.

In this quote, Carles Puigdemont, the former President of Catalonia, frames the pursuit of independence as a necessary step for the region's future. He argues that the alternative to independence for Catalonia is decline, suggesting that staying within the current structure of the Spanish state will lead to deterioration in political, economic, and social terms. Puigdemont emphasizes that the existing relationship between Catalonia and Spain is unhealthy and not conducive to growth or prosperity, and that independence is the only way to avoid this negative trajectory.

Puigdemont's assertion that "everyone knows that" reflects the widespread dissatisfaction with the political and economic status quo in Catalonia, particularly regarding the region's autonomy and treatment by the Spanish government. The lack of a good relationship with Spain, in Puigdemont's view, is a clear barrier to Catalonia’s development and future progress. This dissatisfaction has fueled the push for self-determination and independence in the region, where many believe that greater control over their own affairs would lead to a better future.

The quote highlights the political tension between Catalonia and the Spanish government, which has been marked by disagreements over issues of autonomy and the Catalan independence referendum. Puigdemont’s framing of the situation as a choice between decline and independence reflects his belief that maintaining the current relationship with Spain is unsustainable and detrimental to Catalonia's future.

Ultimately, Puigdemont’s quote stresses that for Catalonia, independence is not just a political desire but a necessity to avoid economic and political stagnation. He presents the choice as stark: without independence, Catalonia will continue to face decline under a relationship with the Spanish state that he believes is fundamentally flawed.