The history of the Jews has been written overwhelmingly by scholars of texts - understandably given the formative nature of the Bible and the Talmud. Seeing Jewish history through artifacts, architecture and images is still a young but spectacularly flourishing discipline that's changing the whole story.

Simon Schama’s quote reflects on the evolving approach to studying Jewish history, which has traditionally been dominated by textual scholarship. He notes that most of the historical narrative has been shaped by scholars of texts, with a strong focus on foundational religious documents like the Bible and the Talmud. This emphasis is understandable, as these texts are central to Jewish religious, cultural, and legal traditions. However, Schama points out that this text-centered view presents only one dimension of a much richer historical tapestry.

The shift he describes involves incorporating artifacts, architecture, and images into the study of Jewish history. These material and visual sources offer alternative ways to understand the lived experiences of Jewish communities across time and space. From synagogue design to everyday household items and historical artworks, these non-textual elements provide insight into aspects of Jewish life that written texts may not fully capture—such as aesthetics, geography, ritual practice, and cultural adaptation.

Schama emphasizes that this young but spectacularly flourishing discipline is not just supplementing the textual tradition but is changing the whole story. By broadening the lens through which Jewish history is examined, scholars are uncovering new narratives, including the experiences of groups and individuals who may have been overlooked in textual sources. This interdisciplinary approach brings a more holistic and inclusive understanding of Jewish identity and heritage, revealing the diversity and complexity of the Jewish experience throughout history.

The quote originates from Schama’s work as a historian, author, and documentary presenter, particularly in his efforts to present Jewish history in a multidimensional way. His contributions, such as the book and television series The Story of the Jews, blend textual analysis with visual storytelling, helping to make this evolving field accessible to broader audiences. Through his work, Schama champions the idea that visual culture and material evidence are essential to understanding the full breadth of historical truth.