Newt Gingrich has a restless and outsized intelligence that is tragically unleavened by any kind of critical sensibility.

In this quote, John Podhoretz critiques Newt Gingrich, highlighting his restless and outsized intelligence, which Podhoretz acknowledges as substantial but argues is tragically unleavened by any sort of critical sensibility. Podhoretz suggests that while Gingrich’s intellectual capacity is undeniable, his thinking lacks the necessary discernment or critical thinking to balance and refine his ideas. The use of "unleavened" implies that, much like dough without yeast, Gingrich’s intelligence is not fully developed or made more effective by the critical perspective that could temper or shape it into something more substantial.

Podhoretz’s critique focuses on the idea that intelligence alone is not enough; it must be paired with the ability to critically assess and question ideas. Without this, intellectual endeavors can become misguided or too one-dimensional. The quote points to Gingrich's style of thinking and public discourse as being marked by boldness and energy, but lacking the nuance and self-awareness that come with a more critical, reflective approach to problem-solving or policy-making.

The origin of this quote is rooted in Podhoretz's perspective as a political commentator and writer. Podhoretz, known for his work as a conservative pundit, often critiques figures on both sides of the political spectrum. In this case, his criticism of Gingrich, a prominent Republican figure, reflects his concern that Gingrich's intellect, while powerful, does not always serve him well because it lacks the balance of critical thought and careful analysis that might guide his more ambitious ideas.

Ultimately, Podhoretz’s statement warns that intelligence without critical sensibility can lead to unbalanced or flawed conclusions. He suggests that true intellectual strength requires the ability to reflect, question assumptions, and temper bold ideas with thoughtful critique—qualities that, in his view, Gingrich may be lacking despite his intellectual brilliance.