I can't see what's wrong about assuming intelligence in your audience and what's bad news about being rewarded for assuming that.

In this quote, Steven Moffat, a celebrated writer and producer known for his work on Doctor Who and Sherlock, defends the idea of assuming intelligence in one’s audience. He suggests that there is nothing wrong with expecting viewers or readers to be discerning and capable of understanding complex narratives. By assuming intelligence, creators can elevate their storytelling, trusting that their audience will engage with the material at a deeper level, rather than simplifying it for the sake of accessibility.

Moffat also touches on the reward that comes from respecting the audience’s intellect. He argues that when creators challenge their viewers to think critically and make connections on their own, the reward is not just critical acclaim but a deeper sense of fulfillment in knowing that the audience appreciated the complexity and nuance of the work. He implies that simplifying or dumbing down content for easier consumption might rob both the creator and the audience of the true potential of the storytelling experience.

The origin of this quote comes from Moffat’s perspective as a storyteller, particularly in his involvement with shows that demand a high level of attention and thought from viewers. His work on shows like Sherlock is often praised for its intricate plots and reliance on an intelligent audience that is willing to engage with the material at a higher level. Moffat has been known to push boundaries in television, crafting narratives that reward viewers who are paying attention and thinking critically.

Ultimately, Moffat’s quote advocates for the importance of trusting the audience’s intelligence and not underestimating their capacity to engage with sophisticated content. It serves as a reminder that intelligence in storytelling can foster a richer, more rewarding experience for both the creator and the audience, leading to a more thoughtful and impactful form of entertainment.